A viral controversy over restaurant diners’ habit of rinsing tableware with hot water has exposed deeper concerns about China’s food safety standards. The practice, known as “tàng wǎn” (烫碗), recently sparked national debate after a professor’s critical comments were taken out of context.
The Cultural Divide
Rooted in Cantonese tea culture, the custom involves pouring boiling water over bowls, chopsticks and cups before eating. Supporters view it as both tradition and practical hygiene measure to remove detergent residue and dust. Critics argue brief contact with warm water provides mere psychological comfort rather than actual sterilization.
Professor Wang Zhongqiu, whose initial “disgust” remark went viral, clarified his intent was to highlight restaurant hygiene standards rather than attack cultural practices. “My comments were selectively edited to provoke regional tensions,” he stated in a May 27 video response.
Scientific Verdict on Sterilization
China’s GB14934-2016 food safety standards mandate zero detectable levels of E. coli or salmonella on tableware – both bacteria linked to severe gastrointestinal illness. Scientific analysis reveals:
- E. coli elimination requires 75°C+ for 1 minute
- Salmonella destruction needs either 100°C instantly or 70°C for 5 minutes
“While theoretically effective with boiling water at sufficient duration, most restaurants serve water below 80°C for mere seconds,” noted food safety expert Dr. Li Wei. “This achieves rinsing at best.”
Recent Hygiene Violations
The debate coincides with troubling findings from nationwide inspections:
- Hainan authorities recently detected E. coli and excess detergent in tableware from Haikou Liudianban Catering
- Beijing Shengjing Yue Restaurant’s bowls tested positive for coliform bacteria in July 2024 spot checks
Path Forward
Food safety advocates emphasize systemic solutions over individual rituals:
- Stricter enforcement of GB14934-2016 standards
- Enhanced disinfection procedures at catering facilities
- Transparent hygiene ratings for restaurants
“The bowl-rinsing debate reflects legitimate public anxiety,” concluded China Consumers Association representative Zhang Min. “Only institutional reforms can truly safeguard diners.”
Related topics：
