In recent years, voices within conservative circles have portrayed America’s declining fertility rate as a moral quandary and a symptom of deteriorating family values. Influential figures like Senator JD Vance and Fox News commentator Ashley St. Clair have publicly criticized childless individuals, suggesting they prioritize personal gratification over familial commitments.
Senator Vance, the Republican vice presidential nominee in 2021, notably disparaged what he termed “childless cat ladies,” criticizing their perceived lack of respect for traditional family values. Last year, St. Clair echoed similar sentiments, condemning those without children for choosing self-indulgence over embracing family life.
Contrary to these assertions, experts argue that the root causes of declining fertility rates are multifaceted and primarily tied to societal and economic challenges rather than mere personal choice. Researchers highlight that the decline in fertility is a global phenomenon, not unique to the United States, reflecting broader issues such as escalating costs of childcare, housing, and economic uncertainty.
“I don’t see this as a lack of commitment to family,” remarked Mary Brinton, a sociologist at Harvard University, as quoted by The New York Times. “The issues are predominantly at the societal and policy levels.”
Since the conclusion of the baby boom era in the mid-1960s, the US fertility rate has steadily declined, with a pronounced drop following the Great Recession of 2008. Kenneth Johnson, a demographer at the University of New Hampshire, noted that despite expectations of a temporary postponement in childbirth due to economic downturns, the anticipated rebound never materialized.
By 2022, the total fertility rate plummeted to a historic low of 1,616.5 births per 1,000 women, well below the replacement level of 2,100 births needed to sustain population size. Recent surveys by the Pew Research Center underscore a growing number of adults opting out of parenthood, a trend that predates the COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, nearly half of US counties reported more deaths than births last year.
Several factors contribute to this downward trend. The average age for marriage and first childbirth has significantly risen, with the median age for first marriages now at 28 and the average age for first births at 27. Financial barriers such as exorbitant housing costs and mounting student debt, coupled with inadequate support for working families, pose substantial obstacles.
Sarah Hayford, director of the Institute for Population Research at Ohio State University, noted that many young adults express a desire for children but face economic and practical barriers hindering their aspirations. Escalating mortgage and childcare expenses, exacerbated by a lack of supportive policies such as paid parental leave, compound these challenges.
Karen Benjamin Guzzo, a sociologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, suggests that diminished optimism about the future also contributes to declining fertility rates. “The decision to have children is the ultimate vote of confidence in the future,” Guzzo remarked. “When fertility rates decline, it reflects a lack of confidence in the future.”
Efforts to reverse this trend have included proposals like former President Donald Trump’s “baby bonus” and Senator JD Vance’s suggestions for tax incentives and electoral reforms to encourage parenthood. Nevertheless, experts caution that these isolated policies have shown limited effectiveness. They advocate instead for comprehensive reforms addressing broader societal issues such as affordable housing, student loan debt, and enhanced parental leave policies as more effective means to stimulate higher birth rates.
“In our perspective, every policy should be considered a family policy,” emphasized Guzzo, underscoring the imperative for holistic changes to support prospective parents and families.
Related Links:
